1 In respect of the EOGM that Mr Lee of the Sale Committee is convening, we note that under the new amendments to the Land Titles (Strata) Act both (a) the terms and conditions of the Collective Sale Agreement and (b) the method of apportionment must first be approved by the EOGM before matters can move further. Since owners of both two and three bedroom apartments are represented among the contributors to this blog, we are, in the interests of fairness and transparency, not taking a position on apportionment. But we would urge you all to examine the apportionment methods that the Sale Committee proposes, and decide for yourselves whether you think they are fair to you, given the scale of your investment in your apartment in Botanic Gardens View.
2 As for the Collective Sale Agreement, we note that Mr Lee's call for an EOGM tried to imply that changes to the Collective Sale Agreement are being made to take account of the new regulations. This is of course debatable. As you will recall, the Sale Committee made changes to the Collective Sale Agreement quite a while ago, after the Horizon Towers judgement made it clear what happens to Sale Committees that act in bad faith. These changes were all to its own benefit and to the detriment of the signatories' legal rights. We are highly doubtful that they will have had the good faith to remove these changes. We therefore urge owners in Botanic Gardens View to consider (and if you support an en-bloc sale to reconsider) carefully, with appropriate legal advice, before agreeing to an en-bloc sale. Among other things, you may wish to ask your legal advisors to:
(a) advise you on the implications of the Sale Committee's power to sell below the reserve price,
(b) the requirement that the signatories indemnify the Sale Committee for their actions, and
(c) how and whether signatories can obtain appropriate protection from the Sale Committee for any losses you may suffer in relation to the en bloc sale.
The benefits of such a sale are illusory, except to the professional speculators, but the damage to our interests and living standards will be real, permanent and irretrievable. The easiest way to protect yourself is to simply refuse to either approve or sign the Collective Sale Agreement.
3 We think it helpful, for the benefit of any newcomers among us, to remind ourselves of the many reasons why this estate has specific reasons not to succumb to the Sale Committee's determination to sell:
The most important reason first. Where do we go?
Botanic Gardens View:
- is freehold
- is in District 10
- is next to the Botanic Gardens
- is next to a major hospital
- is five minutes from Orchard Road and
- has apartments that are very spacious and well-laid-out by current standards
No matter how high a price we get for our homes (and remember that under the most recent version of the Collective Sale Agreement, the Reserve Price may not be the price we sell at as there is provision made for a lower Sale Price), there is no way in the near or distant future that we will be able to afford replacement apartments with all these qualities. None of us will be able to afford to live in the city centre once we are driven from Botanic Gardens View. Most of us who live here do not own more than one property, unlike some members of the Sale Committee.
We have been told ad nauseum over the last few years that for the money we get we can buy brand new apartments with fancy facilities. It was seldom mentioned that at Singapore prices these would all have to be far away in outlying districts. We ask, and keep asking: why should we sacrifice everything that we have now for less? Small flats at higher prices, far from the centre, with far higher conservancy charges,with unnecessary facilities that most of us will not need or use but will still have to pay for? And it is clear that given the housing market in Singapore, most of us will not even have any nest-egg left over, once we have been forced to spend the proceeds of Botanic Gardens View on inferior, substitute accommodation.
4 As the above list reveals, Botanic Gardens View is a unique site. Its long-term value will not go down. Why should a developer reap the benefits of this? We know who will own our estate if we sell, and it will not be ordinary Singaporeans such as ourselves. We consider our homes here to be long-term investments, and we see no reason to throw them away simply so that quick profits can be made at our expense.
Tags:
No comments:
Post a Comment